Hiring Is Not the Finish Line: Keeping Second-Chance Hires Through the First 90 Days
A lot of energy in reentry goes into getting someone hired. Job fairs, resume workshops, employer roundtables, fair-chance pledges. All of that matters. But I have watched too many good placements fall apart in the first few months, and almost never because the person could not do the work.
They fell apart because nobody planned for what happens after the offer letter.
I have spent years inside correctional facilities and alongside the programs that serve people coming home, with programming in 50+ institutions across 12 states. The pattern I see is consistent: the first 90 days on the job are where a second-chance hire is either built to last or quietly lost. If you lead a workforce program, a reentry program or a correctional education department, those 90 days are your work too.
Here is how I would plan for them.
Employers Are More Ready Than We Think
Start with a fact that should change how we talk to employers. In a 2021 survey by SHRM, the SHRM Foundation and the Charles Koch Institute, 85 percent of HR professionals and 81 percent of business leaders said workers with criminal records perform just as well or better in their jobs compared to workers without criminal records (SHRM, "HR More Accepting of Workers with Criminal Records," May 10, 2021).
So the conversation is no longer only about convincing an employer to say yes. It is about helping a willing employer and a motivated new hire get through the stretch where small problems become big ones.
Why the First 90 Days Are Fragile
Think about everything a person may be juggling in the first months home: a supervision schedule, a new address, transportation that may depend on a bus route or a ride from family, a phone plan, a bank account, relationships to rebuild, and often a set of conditions they cannot afford to miss.
Now add a new job with its own schedule, its own unwritten rules and a supervisor who may not know any of that.
When something breaks, it is usually logistics, not effort. A check-in appointment lands on a shift. A ride falls through. A paycheck is delayed and the bus pass runs out. Without someone to call, a person who wants that job badly can lose it over a problem that would have taken ten minutes to solve.
Plan the Handoff Before the Start Date
The best time to protect a placement is before day one. Sit down with the new hire and walk through the first two weeks:
How will you get to work, and what is the backup plan?
Do your supervision appointments conflict with your shift? If so, who needs to know, and who will tell them?
Do you have the clothes, tools, identification and documents the job requires?
Who do you call if something goes wrong before your shift?
Write the answers down. A plan the person helped build is a plan they will use.
Give the Supervisor a Simple Playbook
Frontline supervisors make or break second-chance hiring, and they are rarely trained for it. They do not need a policy manual. They need three things:
A clear point of contact at the reentry or workforce program, with a phone number that gets answered.
Permission to raise concerns early, before they become discipline.
A reminder that feedback and patience in the first weeks are an investment, not special treatment.
When supervisors know who to call, they call before they fire.
Check In on a Schedule, Not Only When There Is Trouble
Most programs check in when something goes wrong. By then it is often too late. I recommend a set rhythm: a call at the end of week one, again at week two, then at day 30, day 60 and day 90. Keep each one short. Ask the new hire what is working and what is getting in the way. Ask the supervisor the same.
Those calls catch the bus route problem, the schedule conflict and the confidence dip before they turn into a missed shift.
Connect the People Around the Hire
A second-chance hire does not succeed alone. Family members, mentors, case managers, supervision officers and the employer each see a different part of the picture. The more those people can share what they know, with the person's consent, the fewer surprises there are.
This is where peer mentors can be especially powerful. Someone who has made it through their own first 90 days carries a credibility nobody else in the room has.
Celebrate the Milestones
Day 30, day 60, day 90. Mark them. A short note from the supervisor, a certificate from the program, a call from the mentor. For someone rebuilding their identity, a milestone is evidence: I am someone who shows up. That evidence matters as much as the paycheck.
The Bottom Line
In my Four Bridges of Reentry, getting the job is the Opportunity Bridge. Keeping it takes the Relationship Bridge and the Identity Bridge too. Programs that only count placements miss half the story. Start measuring retention at 30, 60 and 90 days, and build your support around those dates.
Your Next Step
If you want help designing a first-90-days retention plan for your program or your employer partners, let's talk. Book a call with me at kardellsims.com/book-online.





Comments